How to Win an Adverse Possession Case

Adverse possession is a legal doctrine that allows a person to claim ownership of land under certain conditions, even if they are not the original owner. It is often referred to as “squatter’s rights” and is intended to resolve disputes over land ownership and to promote the productive use of land.

Key Elements of Adverse Possession:

1. Actual Possession:

   • The person claiming adverse possession must physically use the property as an owner would. This can include activities such as living on the land, farming it, maintaining it, or making improvements.

2. Open and Notorious:

   • The possession must be visible and obvious to anyone, including the legal owner. The claimant’s use of the property should be so apparent that it provides notice to the true owner.

3. Exclusive Possession:

   • The claimant must possess the property exclusively, without sharing possession with the true owner or the public. The possession must be continuous and uninterrupted.

4. Hostile Claim:

   • The possession must be without the permission of the true owner. This does not necessarily mean hostility in a personal sense but rather that the claimant is asserting control over the property as if they were the owner.

5. Continuous and Uninterrupted:

   • The claimant must use the property continuously for a period defined by law. This period varies by jurisdiction but typically ranges from 5 to 15 years. The possession must be consistent without long periods of abandonment.

6. Statutory Period:

   • The length of time required for adverse possession to be recognized legally varies by jurisdiction. This period must be met to make a claim for ownership.

Process and Legal Aspects:

1. Filing a Claim:

   • To claim adverse possession, the individual may need to file a legal claim or petition with the court, demonstrating that all the legal requirements have been met.

2. Legal Requirements:

   • The claimant must provide evidence of their possession and use of the property, including documentation and witness testimony.

3. Court Decision:

   • If the court determines that the claimant has met all the requirements for adverse possession, it may issue a ruling confirming their ownership. This ruling typically needs to be recorded with the appropriate land records office.

4. Challenges:

   • The true owner of the property may contest the claim by arguing that the claimant did not meet the legal requirements for adverse possession. The court will review the evidence presented by both parties.

Purpose of Adverse Possession:

• Resolve Land Disputes:

  • Adverse possession helps resolve disputes over land ownership by recognizing claims where the original owner has neglected or abandoned the property.

• Promote Productive Use:

  • It encourages the productive use of land by rewarding those who actively and visibly use and improve the property.

• Clear Title Issues:

  • It helps to clear up ambiguous or disputed land titles, providing legal certainty about property ownership.

Examples:

• Improving Land:

  • A person who builds a house on an unused piece of land and lives there for the required statutory period may claim adverse possession if they meet all legal criteria.

• Farming Land:

  • A farmer who continuously farms land they do not own, while meeting all other requirements, might claim ownership through adverse possession.

Adverse possession is a complex area of law, and specific requirements and procedures can vary widely depending on local laws and regulations. If you believe you might have a claim for adverse possession, consulting with a real estate attorney who specializes in property law can provide guidance and assistance.

Winning an adverse possession case involves meeting specific legal requirements and demonstrating that you have satisfied all the criteria for adverse possession. Adverse possession allows a person to claim ownership of land under certain conditions, even if they are not the original owner. Here’s a guide on how to approach and potentially win an adverse possession case:

1. Understand the Legal Requirements:

Adverse possession laws vary by jurisdiction, but common elements generally include:

• Actual Possession: You must physically use the property as a property owner would, which includes activities like living on it, maintaining it, or using it for a specific purpose.
• Open and Notorious: Your possession of the property must be visible and obvious to anyone, including the legal owner. This means you should use the property in a way that others can see and notice.
• Exclusive Possession: You must possess the property exclusively, without sharing possession with the true owner or the public.
• Hostile Claim: Your possession must be without the permission of the true owner. It doesn’t necessarily mean hostility in the emotional sense but rather that you are claiming the property as your own.
• Continuous and Uninterrupted: You must possess the property continuously for a period defined by law, which varies by jurisdiction. This means you should not have left the property for extended periods or used it intermittently.
• Statutory Period: You must meet the statutory period required by your jurisdiction, which is often 5, 10, or 15 years.

2. Gather Evidence:

• Document Your Possession: Collect evidence showing that you have been in possession of the property. This can include photographs, maintenance records, utility bills, and other documents proving your use of the property.
• Witnesses: Obtain testimonies from neighbors or others who can attest to your possession and use of the property over the statutory period.
• Records: Keep detailed records of any improvements made to the property, such as renovations or repairs.

3. File a Claim:

• Prepare a Legal Claim: Draft and file a legal claim for adverse possession with the appropriate court. This typically involves filing a complaint or petition detailing your claim to the property and your evidence of meeting the legal requirements.
• Legal Representation: Consider hiring a real estate attorney who specializes in adverse possession to assist with preparing and presenting your case. An attorney can help navigate legal complexities and increase your chances of success.

4. Respond to Challenges:

• Defend Against Counterclaims: Be prepared to address any challenges or counterclaims from the current property owner. They may contest your claim by arguing that you did not meet the legal requirements or by presenting evidence to the contrary.
• Prove Your Case: Present your evidence and witness testimony in court to demonstrate that you meet all the legal criteria for adverse possession.

5. Obtain a Court Ruling:

• Court Decision: If the court finds in your favor, it may issue a ruling confirming your ownership of the property. This can involve a court order or a judgment that officially transfers ownership.
• Record the Judgment: Ensure that the court’s decision is properly recorded with the appropriate land or property records office to update the official ownership records.

6. Address Possible Appeals or Additional Steps:

• Appeals: Be aware that the current property owner may appeal the court’s decision. Be prepared to address any appeals or additional legal proceedings.
• Title Transfer: After a favorable ruling, take steps to transfer the property title into your name officially.

Tips for Success:

• Be Thorough and Consistent: Ensure that your claim is well-documented and consistent with the legal requirements for adverse possession.
• Understand Local Laws: Familiarize yourself with the specific adverse possession laws in your jurisdiction, as requirements and procedures can vary.
• Act Promptly: Initiate the process as soon as possible to avoid any potential gaps in your possession or evidence.

Winning an adverse possession case requires careful attention to legal details and thorough preparation. By meeting the legal requirements and presenting a strong case, you can improve your chances of successfully claiming ownership of the property.

Real Estate Expert Witness Services by Craig Cherney, Esq.

Craig Cherney is a trusted client advisor and a sought after real estate lawyer and expert witness who is hired by the nation’s top Real Estate Litigation Attorneys to help resolve their litigated real property matters.  Craig has appeared as a testifying expert witness before judges and juries in California, Arizona, Nevada and other jurisdictions across the country. Craig Cherney, Esq. Expert Witness Real Estate. 480-399-2342.  If you are litigating an easement case, Craig Cherney might be able to help you advance and win your case.